Josh Slattery and Frankie from Aetna podcast graphic

Beyond the benefits: How to evaluate Medicare Advantage plans and carriers this AEP

October 30, 2026•4 min read

A plan your client liked last year may look different this AEP. Benefits are changing, some plans are leaving the market, and provider negotiations can affect whether clients keep access to their doctors and hospitals. You may find yourself revisiting familiar options, explaining changes, and looking for alternatives that still meet your clients' needs.The challenge is looking beyond a plan's benefits to understand whether it's the right fit today and whether the carrier can sustain its offering over time.

On a recent episode of The Broker Link Podcast, Josh Slattery, Executive Vice President of The Brokerage Inc., spoke with Frankie Satterfield-Vaughn, Executive Director, National Distribution at Aetna, about how carriers are navigating the changing Medicare market. Their conversation offers a practical starting point for evaluating plans this AEP.

A Good Plan Has to Work Beyond AEP

Carriers are taking a more deliberate approach to where they compete, and which benefits they offer. Satterfield-Vaughn explained that Aetna's decisions are shaped by star ratings, reimbursement, and provider and hospital contracts. Rather than pursuing growth everywhere, the company is focused on steady, sustainable growth.

That matters when you're comparing plans. An attractive benefit doesn't tell you whether a carrier can sustain its offering or whether the plan fits your client's needs.

As Satterfield-Vaughn explained:

“In every market we have a triple zero. What I mean by that is a zero premium, a zero PCP, zero tier one, you know, drug prices. But that doesn't mean that that's the best thing for that member.”

A zero-premium plan may be the right choice for one client, while another may benefit from paying a modest premium for coverage that better fits their needs. Start with the client, then compare the plans.

Look Beyond the Benefits

What works for one beneficiary may not work for another. A client who relies on a particular specialist may prioritize network access, while someone else may be more concerned about prescription costs or copays.

Provider relationships deserve particular attention. Slattery pointed to Aetna's three-year agreement with Baylor in Dallas as an example of a longer-term arrangement that can provide greater certainty for members. Not every contract will offer that kind of stability, so verify network details rather than assuming negotiations will resolve in your client's favor.

Before recommending a plan, ask:

  • Are the client's doctors, specialists, and preferred hospitals in network?

  • Are their prescriptions covered, and what will they pay?

  • How do premiums, copays, and other out-of-pocket costs fit their budget?

  • If their preferred provider isn't available, are there suitable alternatives?

These checks help you explain not just what a plan offers, but why it makes sense for that particular client.

Put a Plan Behind Your Recommendation

You don't need to predict every change in the Medicare market. You do need a reliable way to evaluate the options in front of you.

As you work through your book this AEP:

  1. Start with the client. Confirm their healthcare needs, providers, prescriptions, and budget before narrowing down plans.

  2. Verify the details. Check current provider networks and coverage information. Don't rely on last year's plan details.

  3. Compare total costs. Look beyond premiums to copays, prescription expenses, and other potential out-of-pocket costs.

  4. Use your carrier contacts. Ask questions about plan changes, network decisions, and available alternatives rather than relying on assumptions.

  5. Make use of training and support. Aetna offers broker support, Aetna Academies, and bid mechanics training. Satterfield-Vaughn encouraged agents to connect with their broker managers and use these resources to understand how plans are designed and why decisions are made.

That last step can help when a plan's benefits or design raise questions. Understanding the reasoning behind a plan gives you more context for explaining its trade-offs to clients.

Help Clients Choose with Confidence

You won't always find a plan that checks every box. Your job is to help clients understand their options, verify the details that affect their coverage, and make informed decisions based on their needs.

That starts with looking beyond headline benefits to consider the carrier's strategy, the provider network, and the costs a client may face throughout the year.

The Brokerage Inc. is here to help you work through questions and navigate the changing Medicare market throughout AEP.

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

Or Watch on Youtube:

This is the first article in a four-part series on navigating Medicare this AEP. Next, we'll explore why ancillary products belong in your AEP conversations, followed by a closer look at provider networks and how to build a Medicare business that lasts beyond AEP.


Back to Blog