Selling Cost Certainty When the Client Is Looking at a Grocery Card
You've probably seen some version of this: a client enrolls in a plan because of its grocery allowance, feels good about the decision in January, and starts looking elsewhere by December when another carrier offers a bigger benefit. The enrollment may have looked like a win, but it hasn't done much for the client relationship.
It's easy to see why supplemental benefits get so much attention. An allowance or grocery card gives clients something tangible to compare, and a larger benefit can make one plan look especially appealing during enrollment. The costs they'll encounter when they visit a doctor, fill a prescription, or need hospital care tend to get less attention, even though those are the expenses they'll be thinking about throughout the year.
Cost certainty can take a little more explaining because there's no card or headline benefit to point to. What you can offer is a clearer picture of what your clients will pay for care and how their coverage fits their needs and budget. When you take the time to walk through those details, clients have a better understanding of what they enrolled in and a clearer sense of whether the plan is right for them. That kind of confidence can go a long way when it's time to review their coverage again next fall.
The Numbers That Are Still True Next September
Elizabeth Davis, VP of National Partnerships at HealthSpring, addressed the industry's tendency to focus on supplemental benefits during her conversation on the Broker Link Podcast.
“We have to get back to focusing on those core medical benefits and not selling the new shiny toy,” she said, pointing to primary care copays, hospital costs, lab work, and prescription expenses. Her point gets to the heart of what clients need to understand when they're choosing coverage: how much they'll pay when they use their plan.
When you're comparing plans with a client, take time to work through the numbers that will shape their healthcare expenses throughout the year:
Primary care and specialist copays
Hospital and other major medical costs
Prescription costs
The plan's annual out-of-pocket maximum
These details give you a more complete picture of what a plan will mean for someone's finances. A grocery allowance might help with everyday expenses, but your clients also need to know what a doctor visit will cost, how their prescriptions are covered, and how much they could be responsible for paying out of pocket over the course of the year.
Supplemental benefits can also change from one plan year to the next, and another carrier may introduce an offering that makes last year's standout benefit look less impressive. That's part of why the underlying coverage deserves so much attention during enrollment. Walking through these details helps clients see how a plan will serve them throughout the year and gives them a clearer basis for weighing its benefits against their healthcare costs
Finding Out Which Client You're Sitting With
Every client brings a different set of priorities to the enrollment conversation. Some will be especially interested in the largest allowance they can get, while others may be more concerned about keeping their doctors, managing prescription costs, or knowing what to expect if they need hospital care. Understanding those priorities early gives you a better sense of what matters to the person sitting across from you and where to focus your conversation.
A few questions can help get that conversation started:
Has a plan ever changed its benefits, network, or costs in a way that caught you off guard?
When you're comparing plans, are you more focused on what you can get right now or on knowing what to expect throughout the year?
If you had to choose between richer supplemental benefits and more predictable healthcare costs, which would matter more to you?
These conversations can tell you a lot about what your client is really looking for. Someone who's had a difficult experience with unexpected changes, for example, may place more value on knowing what to expect from a plan over time. That gives you an opportunity to talk about carrier stability and the business decisions that can influence how a company approaches a market.
You may also have clients who are primarily interested in maximizing their supplemental benefits. Understanding that preference helps you frame the recommendation around what they're looking for while making sure they know how the plan works beyond its extras. The more you understand about a client's expectations, budget, and healthcare needs, the easier it becomes to find a plan that makes sense for them. It also gives you a better starting point for the conversations you'll have when their coverage comes up for review again.
Reading a Market Shift Without Over-Reading It
That understanding of carrier decisions becomes especially useful when something changes in your own market. A product gets repositioned, compensation shifts, or a carrier adjusts its offerings, and naturally, you start thinking about what that means for your business and the clients you've placed. It's worth taking a closer look before deciding what a change signals about the company's plans or its commitment to the broker channel.
Davis spoke directly to HealthSpring's relationship with independent agents during the podcast, noting just how much of the company's business comes through brokers.
“85% of all of our apps are sold through the broker channel,” she said. “We love the broker channel, we always will. That is not changing.”
That gives some important perspective when you're evaluating a product or market adjustment. A carrier can make changes to address conditions in a particular area while continuing to rely heavily on its broker relationships. Understanding what's happening locally can help you separate a market-specific decision from a broader change in the company's approach.
There's also the question of what a product adjustment means for the market. Josh Slattery spoke to that uncertainty during the podcast, explaining that carriers sometimes need to step back and evaluate their position before determining how to move forward.
“It's not that the plan is going to go away,” he said. “It could just be in a healing status, where you're just trying to evaluate the market.”
In practical terms, a carrier may be reassessing its network, costs, or pace of growth in a particular area. If you've seen a product change or become less competitive in your market, it's reasonable to have questions about what comes next. Slattery's point is a reminder that these decisions can be part of an ongoing evaluation rather than a sign that a carrier is preparing to leave.
When those questions come up, you shouldn't have to piece together the answers on your own. The HealthSpring team at The Brokerage Inc. can help you understand what's available in your area, how the network looks, and what a product adjustment means for your business. You can also find resources in BrokerLink. A quick conversation with someone familiar with the market can save you time and give you a much clearer picture of what's happening.
Where This Shows Up in Your Next Appointment
The next time a client leads with a question about a grocery allowance or another supplemental benefit, take a few minutes to walk through the medical costs behind the plan. Make sure they understand what they'll pay for care, whether their doctors and prescriptions are covered, and how the plan fits their budget throughout the year.
The same approach applies when something changes in your market. Take the time to find out what's driving the decision, talk with the HealthSpring team, and get a clear understanding of what it means before bringing that information to your clients.
Ultimately, the more you understand about the people you're working with, the better equipped you are to recommend coverage that fits their needs and expectations. Those conversations are also what help build trust over time. Clients remember when you took the time to understand what mattered to them and helped them make a decision, they felt good about.
That same support is available whenever you need it. Explore HealthSpring resources in BrokerLink, and hear the full conversation between Josh Slattery and Elizabeth Davis on The Brokerage Inc.’s podcast, The Broker Link.
