Josh Slattery and Frankie Satterfield-Vaughn Podcast Blog 2

Why ancillary products belong in your AEP conversations

November 04, 2026•5 min read

When you're reviewing Medicare Advantage coverage with a client, the conversation often starts with premiums, benefits, and provider networks. But those details don't tell the whole story. What happens if a client needs a hospital stay? How would they manage the costs associated with a serious illness or an extended recovery?

Those questions can open the door to a conversation about ancillary coverage.

On an episode of The Broker Link, The Brokerage Inc.'s podcast, Frankie Satterfield-Vaughn of Aetna offered a direct recommendation for agents navigating the changing Medicare market: “Every single agent that sells MA needs to understand ancillary.”

Look Beyond the Plan's Benefits

As maximum out-of-pocket limits and hospital copays rise, it’s worth helping clients understand what their coverage could mean when they need care. A plan may meet their immediate needs and still leave costs they want to prepare for.

Ancillary products can help address some of those concerns, depending on the coverage, the client's circumstances, and what's available in their area. Frankie highlighted several options during her conversation with Josh Slattery, Executive Vice President at The Brokerage Inc.:

  • Hospital indemnity: May help with certain expenses associated with a hospital stay.

  • Recovery care: May provide support when a client faces an extended recovery or longer-term care needs, including the demands placed on caregivers.

  • Cancer, heart attack, and stroke coverage: May offer additional financial protection in the event of a covered diagnosis.

These products aren't right for everyone, and they don't replace Medicare Advantage coverage. The point is to understand what matters to each client and whether additional protection addresses a concern their existing coverage doesn't fully resolve.

AEP Is an Opportunity to Ask Different Questions

You already have a reason to review coverage with clients during AEP. Use that conversation to ask how they would manage costs beyond their premium and routine care.

Consider asking:

  • What concerns you most about unexpected healthcare expenses?

  • How would a hospital stay affect your finances?

  • Do you have concerns about the costs or demands of recovering from a serious illness?

  • Would you like to explore additional coverage, and does it fit your budget?

You don't need to recommend an ancillary product every time. You do need to recognize when a client's answers warrant a closer look.

There's also a business consideration. Frankie noted that ancillary products can provide a source of compensation during AEP, when Medicare Advantage commissions aren't paid during the enrollment period. Understanding the products you're contracted to offer, along with their coverage and limitations, can help you identify appropriate options when a client needs them.

Aetna makes its ancillary products available to contracted agents through Think Agent, with training available to help agents understand what they offer.

Build the Relationship, Not Just the Sale

Josh raised another reason for agents to understand ancillary products: diversification. With continued pressure on Medicare Advantage, relying on one product line can leave an agency more exposed to changes in the market. He compared it to an investment portfolio, pointing out that few people would want nearly all their investments tied to a single asset. Yet many agents have built businesses where Medicare Advantage accounts for nearly all their production.

For agents looking to build a more balanced business, ancillary products can offer another avenue, provided they fit the client's needs and the agent is properly contracted to offer them.

There’s a client relationship benefit, too. Frankie compared it to bundling home and auto insurance. When clients have multiple coverage needs handled by someone they trust, they're more likely to maintain that relationship rather than look elsewhere. As she explained:

“You aren't going to look for a different agent because you now have two products with that same agent. If that agent does their job right, that client's going to be with them forever.”

The point isn't to add products simply to increase production. It's to understand the broader needs of the people you serve and be in a position to help when those needs extend beyond Medicare Advantage. Putting that approach into practice starts with knowing what to look for during your next client conversation.

What to Do Next

As you work through AEP, make ancillary coverage part of your review process:

  1. Ask about financial concerns. Understand what your client worries about beyond their monthly premium.

  2. Identify potential gaps. Discuss relevant hospital, recovery, or critical illness expenses without assuming additional coverage is necessary.

  3. Review appropriate options. Check what's available in your client's area, confirm eligibility and coverage details, and explain the costs and limitations.

  4. Use your resources. Review product training and available tools, including Think Agent for Aetna's ancillary offerings, if you're contracted to sell them.

  5. Let the client decide. Make a recommendation based on their needs and budget, not simply the opportunity to add a product.

The Brokerage Inc. is here to help you navigate product questions, find training, and understand the options available to you. If you're unsure where to start, reach out for support.

AEP is an opportunity to review more than the plan a client will enroll in. It's a chance to understand the costs they're concerned about, help them evaluate their options, and strengthen the relationship that brings them back to you year after year.

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

Or Watch on Youtube:

This is part two of a four-part series on navigating Medicare this AEP. Part one explored why a zero-premium plan or attractive benefits don't automatically make a plan the right choice for every beneficiary. Part three looks at the provider networks behind the benefits, and part four explores how to build a Medicare business that lasts beyond AEP.


Back to Blog