Josh and Frankie

The network behind the benefits

November 13, 2026•4 min read

A client wants to keep seeing their doctor. You've found a Medicare Advantage plan with benefits that fit their needs, but there's a problem: the provider's contract is still being negotiated. Do you assume it will work out before the new plan year, as it might have in the past?

Josh Slattery, Executive Vice President at The Brokerage Inc., says that assumption is becoming harder to make. During an episode of The Broker Link, he described how provider negotiations have grown more contentious, sometimes making headlines and prompting letters to patients.

These market uncertainties change the conversations you’re having with your clients. It’s no longer enough to compare benefits and hope a contract gets resolved. You need to know what’s confirmed, what’s still uncertain, and how that uncertainty could affect the person you’re advising.

The 11th-Hour Deal Isn't a Given

Slattery recalled a time when agents could expect many provider negotiations to come together before the new plan year. That expectation is less reliable now.

As he put it:

“But we can't really say that anymore because the provider negotiations are getting really more intensified. They end up in the media. Letters are going out to patients.”

A contract may still be under negotiation, but your client has a decision to make. If their preferred doctor or hospital is central to their care, uncertainty about that relationship deserves attention before they enroll, not after.

You don't have to predict the outcome of a negotiation. You do need to help your client understand the information available and what alternatives they might have if the agreement doesn't come together.

What Makes a Network Sustainable?

Provider negotiations aren't simply about whether a carrier wants to keep a particular doctor or hospital. The financial terms matter, too.

Frankie Satterfield-Vaughn of Aetna explained that maintaining a larger network can mean paying more to providers.

“Because the larger the provider network, sometimes the higher the contracts you have to pay.”

Carriers have to weigh those costs against claims, quality, reimbursement, and the long-term sustainability of their plans. A network that's too narrow can limit access, while a broader one can come with higher contract costs. Those competing pressures help explain why a carrier might decide not to renew a provider agreement.

The takeaway is that a larger or smaller network isn’t automatically better. Network size alone doesn’t tell you whether a plan will work for your client. Their doctors, hospitals, healthcare needs, and available alternatives matter far more than a network’s size on paper.

What a Longer-Term Agreement Can Tell You

During the conversation, Satterfield-Vaughn pointed to Aetna's three-year agreement with Baylor in Dallas as an example of a longer-term provider arrangement.

She emphasized that it was a three-year deal, not a one-year agreement, connecting that longer commitment to member stability.

An agreement like this can provide a different level of certainty than a contract still being negotiated. It also illustrates why the status and terms of a provider relationship deserve a place in your plan evaluation.

Of course, a longer-term agreement isn't a guarantee that every aspect of a network will remain unchanged. But understanding what's been agreed to, and for how long, gives you useful context when comparing options for a client who depends on that provider.

Before You Recommend a Plan, Check the Network

You can't control carrier negotiations. You can make network verification a deliberate part of your AEP process.

When comparing plans with a client, take these steps:

  1. Identify the providers they need to keep. Ask about their doctors, specialists, and preferred hospitals before narrowing down plan options.

  2. Verify current network participation. Check the available provider information for each plan. Don't assume last year's network still applies.

  3. Clarify what's unresolved. If a contract is under negotiation, distinguish confirmed information from what has yet to be decided.

  4. Discuss alternatives. If a preferred provider may not be available, help your client understand their other options and whether those options meet their needs.

  5. Weigh access alongside cost and benefits. Consider the network in the context of premiums, copays, prescriptions, and the coverage your client is likely to use.

These checks won't eliminate uncertainty, but they can help you identify potential problems before enrollment and explain your recommendations more clearly.

Your Value Is in What You Help Clients Understand

No carrier can promise that every provider relationship will remain unchanged. And no single plan will be the right fit for every beneficiary.

What you can do is make sure provider access is part of the decision from the start. Verify the details, explain what remains uncertain, and help clients weigh the trade-offs before they enroll. That's where your guidance matters. When a client understands not just what a plan offers, but how it fits their healthcare relationships, they're better equipped to make an informed choice.

The Brokerage Inc. is here to help you work through plan questions and navigate the changing Medicare market throughout AEP.

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

Or Watch on Youtube:

This is part three of our four-part series on navigating Medicare this AEP. Part one explored why a plan's headline benefits don't always make it the right fit, and part two examined where ancillary products may fit into client conversations. In part four, we'll look at building a Medicare business that lasts beyond AEP.


Back to Blog